Square suits the widest range of new and mixed businesses, Toast and SpotOn lead for restaurants, Toast on depth and SpotOn on its choice of plans, Clover offers the broadest hardware range, and Shopify POS fits brands that also sell online. Lightspeed and TouchBistro suit specialty retail and independent restaurants, KORONA POS lets shops keep their own processor, and Helcim and Loyverse keep software costs at or near zero. Three practical questions follow: whether you must accept cash, what happens when the internet drops, and whether your hardware moves with you if you change processors.
Do businesses have to accept cash?
In a growing number of places, yes. Pew Research Center counted at least 10 states and 10 local governments in November 2026 that require in-person businesses to accept cash, with exceptions: Massachusetts since 1978, New Jersey, Rhode Island, Colorado, Connecticut, Oregon, Delaware and Montana, New York State from March 21, 2026 and Maryland from October 1, 2026, along with cities and counties including San Francisco, Philadelphia, New York City, Washington, D.C., Miami-Dade County and Detroit; Illinois has passed a law that starts on January 1, 2028. New York’s state law allows penalties of up to $1,000 for a first violation and $1,500 for later ones, though stores may refuse bills larger than $20. A federal Payment Choice Act, covering in-person purchases up to $500, has been introduced in Congress but has not become law, so check your state and city rules before going cashless.
Can a POS keep taking cards when the internet goes down?
Most can, with limits and at your risk. Square allows offline payments automatically unless you opt out, for up to $50,000 per transaction; payments taken on its Register, Terminal or Handheld must upload within 72 hours, those on readers and Stand within 24 hours, and expired, declined or disputed offline payments are the seller’s responsibility. Toast asks that devices come back online within three days, preferably within 24 hours, and lets managers set an amount above which offline payments need approval; Clover’s help pages describe offline payments for up to seven days on its terminals but not on the Clover Go reader; and Shopify POS requires you to switch offline payments on and set daily and per-order limits. Because a card that fails once the connection returns can’t be charged again, keep offline limits low and ask for another payment method on large tickets.
Will my POS hardware work if I switch payment processors?
Often not. Clover states that its devices, even when bought or leased from another company, cannot be used with other payment processors; Toast requires customers to use its own payment processing and may require hardware to be returned when service ends; and Square’s community and developer forums say its payment hardware processes cards only through Square. Toast’s merchant agreement charges pay-as-you-go customers who leave early $150 for each remaining month, and equipment leases arranged through resellers carry their own terms. Systems sold as software only, such as KORONA POS, work with many processors, so read the term and early-termination sections before buying any device.