Square and PayPal’s point-of-sale app are the easiest ways to start taking cards in person, Stripe leads for online and app-based sales, Toast for restaurants, and QuickBooks Payments and Chase for businesses already tied to those companies; Helcim and Stax give growing businesses near-wholesale pricing, Clover offers premium hardware on longer contracts, and Authorize.net remains a common gateway for card-not-present sales through a bank merchant account. Further down, we compare pricing models, explain when you can pass card fees on to customers and look at what the Visa and Mastercard settlement would change.
Flat-rate, interchange-plus or subscription pricing: which costs less?
It depends on your volume and card mix. Every card sale carries interchange, which Visa describes as a fee passed between the merchant’s bank and the card-issuing bank, plus network fees; the merchant pays a discount rate to its processor that bundles those costs with the processor’s margin. Flat-rate processors such as Square, PayPal and Chase fold everything into one price, about 2.3% to 2.7% plus a few cents in person, which is simple but charges the same on low-cost debit cards as on premium rewards cards. Interchange-plus pricing, as at Helcim, passes the actual interchange through and adds a disclosed margin, and subscription models such as Stax charge a monthly fee plus a few cents per transaction instead of a percentage. Debit cards from large banks are cheap to accept because the Federal Reserve’s Regulation II caps their interchange at 21 cents plus 0.05% plus a 1-cent fraud adjustment; a federal appeals court on October 26, 2026 upheld a ruling against that cap, which stays in force until the decision takes effect. Ask each processor to price a sample month at your own volume and compare the effective rate, total fees divided by total card sales.
Can we charge customers a fee for paying by card?
Often, but only on credit cards and only within the rules. Visa lets US merchants add a surcharge to credit card payments that may not exceed their cost of acceptance or 3%, requires them to notify their acquirer 30 days before they begin and expects the fee to be disclosed to customers before they pay. States add their own limits: Connecticut and Massachusetts prohibit credit card surcharges, Colorado caps them at 2%, New York has required sellers since February 2024 to show the total price including any surcharge, and California’s junk-fee law, in force since July 2024, requires fees that customers cannot avoid to be included in advertised prices. Some processors here, Helcim among them, offer surcharging settings, but check the rules in every state where you sell before switching them on.
What would the Visa and Mastercard settlement change for small businesses?
Lower costs on rewards cards and more choice, if it wins final approval. Under the revised settlement of the long-running merchant class action, Visa says it would cut the combined average effective US credit interchange rate by 0.1 percentage point for five years, cap posted US credit interchange rates for five years and keep standard consumer credit rates at no more than 1.25%, while merchants could decline whole categories of credit cards, such as premium consumer or commercial cards, and would gain more room to surcharge. Judge Brian Cogan of the federal court in Brooklyn granted preliminary approval on June 9, 2026, but Walmart and merchant groups including the National Retail Federation have objected, and we found no final approval as of late November 2026. Until any change takes effect, the pricing model you choose matters more than the settlement.