KnowBe4 offers the broadest catalog at posted prices; Huntress and Wizer cost the least for a small team, and Microsoft’s simulator may already sit in your license. Proofpoint and Mimecast fit best beside their own email security, Hoxhunt and Adaptive lead on simulations beyond email, NINJIO on watchable video and SANS on compliance libraries for the public sector. The FAQ that follows covers the laws that mandate training, the research on whether it changes behavior and how to prepare staff for deepfake calls.
Which laws require security awareness training?
Several, depending on your industry. The FTC’s Safeguards Rule requires the financial institutions it covers, a group that includes tax preparers and car dealers that lease vehicles, to give staff security awareness training that is updated to reflect the risks found in their risk assessment. The HIPAA Security Rule requires covered entities and business associates to run a security awareness and training program for all members of the workforce, management included, though it sets no fixed schedule. PCI DSS version 4.0.1 requires training at hire and annually thereafter, and since March 31, 2025, that training must cover phishing and social engineering. Under the FBI’s CJIS Security Policy, people with access to criminal justice information must be trained before they get access and annually after that, and under the NISPOM rule, 32 CFR 117.12, defense contractors must give all cleared employees security education and training every 12 months and keep participation records. Whatever platform you choose, export its completion reports, because they are the evidence auditors and regulators ask to see.
Does phishing training actually work?
Less than vendors suggest, if training is the only defense. An eight-month randomized study of more than 19,500 UC San Diego Health employees, presented at the IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy in 2025, found no significant relationship between completing annual training and falling for phishing, and the lessons shown after a click cut the chance of clicking by only 2%; three-quarters of users spent a minute or less on them, and a third closed them immediately. The lure mattered far more: 1.82% clicked a fake Outlook password notice, but 30.8% clicked a message about a new vacation policy. Vendor data is more upbeat, with KnowBe4’s 2026 benchmark reporting simulated-phishing failure rates falling from 33.2% to 4.2% after a year of training and testing, though those are its own simulations rather than real attacks. Treat training as one layer: track how many people report suspicious messages, not just how many click, and back it up with two-factor authentication and password managers, the controls the UC San Diego researchers recommend.
How do we prepare staff for deepfake and voice-clone scams?
Fix the process first, then rehearse it. In early 2024 an Arup employee in Hong Kong sent about HK$200 million, roughly US$25 million, in 15 transfers after a video call in which the firm’s chief financial officer and other colleagues were deepfakes, and in May 2025 the FBI warned that criminals were impersonating senior US officials with texts and AI-generated voice messages. The FBI’s advice works inside a company too: verify anyone who calls or texts by finding their number independently and calling back, never share a two-factor code, and never send money or gift cards to people you do not know. Turn that into policy, with a second approver for payments and bank-detail changes and a callback rule for urgent requests from executives, then test it: Adaptive Security and Hoxhunt run deepfake video and cloned-voice simulations, and KnowBe4 added simulated voice phishing in October 2026.