For a small HR team the first filter is the yearly minimum: Small Improvements asks $3,000, Lattice $4,000 and Engagedly $7,500, while PerformYard publishes no minimum and Leapsome lets new customers test it before buying. Lattice, 15Five, Leapsome and Culture Amp are the mainstream picks for growing companies, Betterworks and Workday serve large employers, and Workleap’s per-manager pricing favors companies with large teams under each manager. Run one real review cycle during a trial or pilot, including calibration and the sync with your HR system, before you sign. The questions that follow cover annual reviews versus continuous feedback, how OKRs are scored and how to keep 360 feedback fair.
Do annual reviews still work, or should we switch to continuous feedback?
Few employees find the annual version useful: Gallup reported in 2019 that only 14% of employees strongly agree their performance reviews inspire them to improve, and that nearly half hear from their manager about their work a few times a year or less. The same research found that people who get weekly rather than annual feedback are 5.2 times more likely to strongly agree that the feedback they receive is meaningful and 2.7 times more likely to be engaged at work. A common middle path is to keep a formal review for pay and promotion decisions and add short, frequent check-ins between cycles, which is what the one-on-one and check-in tools in these products are built for.
What are OKRs, and how are they scored?
OKRs, short for objectives and key results, pair an ambitious objective with a few measurable results that show whether it was reached; John Doerr learned the method from Andy Grove at Intel and later brought it to Google. Google’s re:Work guide grades each key result from 0.0 to 1.0 and puts the sweet spot at 60% to 70%, since scoring a full 1.0 every time suggests the goals were too safe. The guide also warns that OKRs are not synonymous with performance evaluation, and Doerr’s What Matters site draws the line with KPIs this way: KPIs monitor the steady state, while OKRs describe the outcomes you want to change. Lattice and Leapsome sell goals and OKRs as a module separate from reviews, which makes that split easy to keep.
How should 360-degree feedback be run?
Keep it for development, protect anonymity and calibrate the ratings that feed pay. The Center for Creative Leadership advises telling everyone involved that a 360 is an assessment for development, not a performance appraisal or part of a salary or promotion review, notes that anonymous raters are more likely to give candid, objective feedback and requires a minimum number of raters in each category so peers and direct reports cannot be singled out. Feedback can also backfire: a 1996 meta-analysis by Avraham Kluger and Angelo DeNisi found that over one-third of the feedback interventions it studied made performance worse. For the ratings that do drive pay, calibration sessions, which SHRM describes as a way to ensure that different managers apply similar standards, offset tough and easy graders, though Harvard Business Review reported in 2024 that the meetings can introduce bias of their own.