Smith.ai is the strongest all-round choice, with a free AI tier and trained North American receptionists behind it, and RingCentral’s AI Receptionist suits businesses that want a large provider and multilingual answering on any phone system. Upfirst and Rosie are the budget picks, Goodcall suits businesses with many repeat callers, and Abby Connect and Ruby suit owners who still want people answering most calls. For specific industries, Slang.ai handles restaurant reservations and Sameday AI books jobs for the trades, while Newo.ai suits companies that want one agent across calls, chat and social messages. Three legal and practical questions follow: recording consent, callbacks and texts, and when a person should take over.
Is it legal for an AI receptionist to record calls?
Usually, if callers are told. Federal law allows recording when one party to the call consents, but California, Delaware, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Montana, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania and Washington generally require every party’s consent, as do Connecticut and Nevada for phone calls and Michigan in some situations, according to the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, and California’s Supreme Court has applied its stricter rule to out-of-state companies recording calls with Californians. A recorded notice at the start of the call is the usual fix, because callers who stay on after a clear warning are generally treated as consenting. AI vendors add a further risk: in August 2025 a federal judge in California let a privacy lawsuit proceed against ConverseNow, whose AI takes phone orders for Domino’s, partly because it allegedly used call data to improve its own AI, and a similar suit over Google’s contact-center AI survived an early dismissal bid in February 2025. Turn on the recording notice your receptionist offers, and ask the vendor whether it trains its models on your calls.
Can an AI receptionist call or text customers back?
Yes, but outbound contact brings in federal rules that mostly concern calls a business makes rather than calls it answers. In February 2024 the Federal Communications Commission ruled that AI-generated voices count as an “artificial or prerecorded voice” under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, so calls that use them need the called party’s prior express consent, and prior express written consent if the call markets something. Texts have their own gatekeeper: US carriers require businesses texting from ordinary 10-digit numbers to register their brand and messaging campaign through The Campaign Registry, and Twilio warns that unregistered traffic draws extra carrier fees. Before switching on callbacks or follow-up texts, make sure your intake forms or the call itself capture consent, and confirm the vendor has registered the number it texts from.
When should a call go to a person instead of the AI?
Whenever the caller asks, and whenever the stakes or emotions run high: complaints, emergencies, billing disputes, legal or medical questions and anyone who has already repeated themselves. Most tools here let you set those rules: RingCentral hands calls to users, extensions, queues or outside numbers with a written summary, Upfirst and Rosie can try several numbers in turn until someone answers, Slang.ai connects restaurant guests to staff the moment they ask, and Smith.ai and Abby Connect can pass a call to their own human receptionists on the same line when your team is busy. Test the handoff before going live by calling in with a hard question, and review recordings in the first weeks to adjust what the AI handles alone.